Historical Purposes

Porcupine Festival 2005 Info

Porc Fest Logo
welcome to the

2005 Porcupine Freedom Festival

(AKA  PorcFest '05)


Latest News

PhotosReportsMerchandise



ScheduleWe'll Be There ListRegister for PorcFestLodgingPublicityRide ShareRoom Share

WHAT:PorcFest '05 is the second annual Free State Project gathering in New Hampshire.  It's open to anyone interested in freedom or the Free State Project.  You can see what PorcFest '04 was like.
WHEN:July 23-31, 2005. You don't have to attend all days, but we'd love to have you! Take advantage of Roger's discount (see below) and come early!  Click here for the schedule of events.
WHERE: Most of the festival will be held at Roger's Campground, in Lancaster, NH.  Here are directions. Some events will be off-site.
WHO:All liberty lovers (especially Porcupines!) are encouraged to attend and invite their friends and neighbors.
WHY:

1) Build camaraderie with fellow Porcupines
2)
Get to know and love NH
3) Learn how to make the transition to living there, including tips from those who have made the move
4)
Increase your activism capability with motivational speakers and activism training with which you can help build the FSP and promote freedom no matter where you live
5) Learn more about the FSP and get a personal look at what's going on in NH

PRICE:There is no admission charge for PorcFest '05 although some extra-curricular activities may have a small charge. For those who do not stay at Roger's Campground, there is a small daily entrance fee charged by Roger's.

Roger's pricing is Motel: $76/night, Tent site $23 (with electricity $24, with electricity and water $25), and an RV site is $35. Roger's has many amenities, including awe-inspiring vistas, three swimming pools and a waterslide, a playground for the kids, on-site restaurant, modern lavatories/showers with hot and cold running water, and most importantly, LOTS of Porcupines!

SCHEDULE:  
See the Schedule of Events page here
NEXT STEPS:

1) Make a reservation: Be sure to mention you are with the Free State Project in order to get the FSP pricing. You can contact Roger's via e-mail at rogers@ncia.net, via phone at 603-636-1062, via fax at 603-788-3697, or via snail mail at Roger's Campground, 10 Roger's Campground Rd., Lancaster, NH 03584. Additional nearby lodging information.

2) Register for PorcFest '05 here!

3) Invite a friend or neighbor to attend with you

4) Visit this PorcFest page regularly for updates, and see how many plan to come on the We'll Be There list.



GOT QUESTIONS? Please contact Varrin Swearingen at varrin@freestateproject.org with any questions about PorcFest '05.

Congratulations to Fox Tree for submitting the winning entry (see top of this page) to the Porc Fest Art Contest.  Thanks to all who participated!

NH Links

This page is here for reference purposes.

A Re-Examination of the State Comparison Matrix

A Re-Examination of the State Comparison Matrix

by Jason S.

 

State Report ID 2: A Free State for Idaho

A Free State for Idaho: A Second Report from Idaho

by Hari Heath

Idaho is under consideration to become the Free State. Why should Idaho become the Free State? Under various criteria established by the FSP, Idaho falls somewhere near the middle to the front of the pack. Idaho has more diverse opportunities than most of the other states in contention. Idaho has a moderate climate, a pre-existing "liberty" culture, varied geography and economic opportunities, and a quality of life that can be enjoyed across the spectrum, from remote wilderness settings to modern, urban environments.

Idaho, especially once you step out of the Boise beltway (where the current socialists in office "work" and play), is one of America's few remaining liberty cultures. Those who have been here a generation or more are likely to have come from that independent pioneer or native stock.

Recent migrations have seen many move to Idaho who wanted to get away from the more "developed" states. Some have blended into Idaho culture and some have brought their former lifestyles with them. Idaho now has a mix of comfortable living in urban/suburban settings and rural lifestyle opportunities.

Idaho Politics

Politically, Republicans have dominated Idaho for years. There are many reasons for this. Generally, Idaho is an independent, conservative, and individualistic society. Traditionally north Idaho is the main refuge for Democrats. Those Democrats, however, often tend to behave like Republicans. On the other hand, many "Democrats" joined the Republican Party some time ago so they could get elected. So some of our Republicans tend to behave like Democrats.

The Libertarians of Northern Idaho fielded more candidates this year than the Democrats did. Given the weak standing of the nearly DOA Democratic Party, it would not take a monumental effort for the Libertarians to become the second most powerful party. That would provide the opportunity to inject Libertarian issues into the Idaho political debate.

Most Idahoans are unfamiliar with the Libertarian platform. There are a lot of Libertarians in Idaho that just don't know it yet. The Constitution Party has also made a good showing this year, with potential for improvement.

If the FSP moves to Idaho, a "Liberty Party" or coalition of Libertarians, Constitution Party members, and free-thinking Republicans could be put together to develop some in-state political clout and challenge Idaho's Republican guard.

Twenty-thousand liberty activists could go a long way in Idaho. There aren't 20,000 republican and democratic activists in Idaho now. Idaho uses the caucus system. In some of the less populated counties, it would not be inconceivable for 10 or 20 "activists" to show up at either the Republican or Democratic caucus, take it over, run their own candidates, and knock incumbents and conventional candidates down to write-in status.

An unintended result of so many activists moving to a state with a liberty agenda would be the eventual exodus of dyed-in-the wool socialists. Those who want to get their good life from the taxes of others will have to move to greener pastures once the "bennies" dry up.

The wheels of socialism have been turning in Idaho like anywhere else in modern America. There will be resistance from the "there-oughta-be-a-law" politicians currently in power. And the hordes of agency employees will not go away with out a fight.

Local Government

Idaho's 44 counties use a three-Commissioner system for their management. Obtaining two of those seats by Porcupine-inclined activists would give broad control of county government. Commissioners, in addition to being the executive head of the county, have the power to pass or repeal ordinances. They also have limited judicial powers to hold hearings and determine certain issues. A modicum of effort could establish a "free county." This could become the base of operation for the establishment of a "Free State."

The Idaho legislature and people passed a constitutional Amendment a few years back allowing for optional forms of county government. The intent was to promote more socialistic forms of county government, but it also opens the door to "optional forms of county government," giving Porcupines some room for creative governance.

Citizen Initiatives and Referendums

Idaho has one of the best opportunities in the nation for direct citizen legislation. As a constitutionally-enshrined right, the people can make laws through the initiative process, or repeal legislation with a referendum. With one of the longest signature gathering periods in the country and reasonable initiative and referendum process requirements, Porcupines will be able to create a Free State "by first reforming state law."

The Idaho Constitution can be amended after a proposed amendment is passed by a super majority of both the Senate and the House, and then ratified by a simple majority vote of the people. A Porcupine legislature, with the consent of the people, could add liberty teeth to our state Constitution.

One Initiative is currently in process, that, if passed, will definitely help ensure Idaho's free state. The Idaho Judicial Accountability Act of 2004 will create a citizens commission to hear complaints of judicial misconduct and hold judicial officers accountable to the laws and Constitution. Once the judiciary is bound to obey the law, the legislative and executive branches will be compelled to follow.

Guns

Guns are a traditional component of Idaho culture. Gun stores, gun shows, and shooting ranges, informal and organized, are common in Idaho. Concealed carry permits are easy to get, as long as you provide fingerprints and pass a federal background check. Only convicted felons, drug addicts, and those declared mentally infirm can be denied a concealed carry permit in Idaho. Permit holders are exempt from the federal waiting period and background checks for gun purchases. State law allows concealed carry without a permit when you are not in a vehicle or an incorporated town. The state Constitution prohibits restrictive local gun laws and any firearms registration scheme.

As reasonable as they currently are, Idaho's gun laws could be improved. An unlicensed concealed carry law could be passed by a Porcupine legislature and replace the current concealed weapons license. An Idaho "Free State" could challenge the unconstitutional National Firearms Act of 1934 and the Gun Control Act of 1968. These and other federal disarmament laws could be repealed, at least within the "autonomous" borders of a free Idaho.

A Free State Militia

Idaho's Constitution already provides for a state militia. A Porcupine legislature could fulfill its constitutional duties to "enroll, equip and discipline" every able-bodied male between 18 and 45 to ensure Idaho's sovereign autonomy.

Federal Equations

The amount of federal land ownership in a state is being considered by the FSP for both positive and negative factors. "More federal land ownership might mean an excuse for federal meddling in the state, but it could also mean a legitimate grievance for the state's citizens."

Federal dependence, particularly whether a state receives more or less federal funding than it pays in federal taxes, is also factor being given consideration. States that get more federal handouts than they pay for are likely to be harder to wean from federal socialism. Idaho is in the middle of the pack of the FSP contenders on this issue.

The federal government claims to "own" two-thirds of Idaho under the presumptive administrative authority of The Forest Service and the BLM. There are considerable grounds for Idaho citizens to have a legitimate grievance. Especially when history, the current lethargic federal management schemes, and the constitutional facts of life are considered. The federal Constitution prohibits the federal government from owning any lands within a state except for certain military purposes and other needful buildings, and then, only after being purchased with the consent of the state legislature. The Idaho Constitution conveyed all property of the Idaho territory to the new state upon admission to the union. The Congress accepted, ratified, and confirmed the state Constitution in the Idaho Admission Act. But unconstitutional Presidential Proclamations usurped much of the Idaho public lands soon after it became a state (see The Big Lie) Two-thirds of Idaho is currently "administered" by a federal government which has no lawful authority to do so and is therefore prohibited by the Tenth Amendment from owning "public" forest and range lands.

Why doesn't Idaho resume management of the public lands fraudulently held by the federal government? Because the current political powers in Idaho don't want to rock the boat and risk losing their federal handouts. What would be the result if Free State activists assumed a majority position in state government and chose to give up all the federal handouts (which they plan to do anyway) and reassumed ownership of the two-thirds of Idaho that was unconstitutionally "taken"? Vast public resources, the size of any eastern state, could be managed by those most able to do so – the people who live here. Forestlands, mineral properties, rangelands, recreational resources, and even wilderness can be managed under the Idaho state motto – esto perpetua.

Resources

One criteria that appears to be missing from the FSP's evaluation of the states is resources. Especially natural ones. How can a state be independent and self reliant without the means to do so? The resource oversight is understandable, considering many of the FSP's founders are from the more urban eastern states, where resources are more likely to be acquired in commerce than by development.

The relative qualities and quantities of each prospective state's resources appears to have escaped the FSP's consideration. Western states typically have a much greater quantity and diversity of resources than the eastern states, and have populations of people who know what to do with them.

Sometimes known as the gem state, Idaho has abundant gems, precious and industrial metals, and minerals. Mining was one of the first post-European settlement activities.

Agriculture is common throughout Idaho and is a major component of the Idaho economy. Productive land is an important resource for any self-reliant Porcupine.

Idaho has supplied a wide variety of forest products for well over a century. We also have wilderness areas (nearly the size of New Hampshire) and other forestlands. With 20,000 activists to help wean us from federal handouts and work to reassume ownership of Idaho's federally occupied public lands, prospects could be good for Free State Idahoans. An accountable state government and the teeth of our current State Constitution's corporations article, could provide excellent management of our public lands while preventing some of the past corporate abuses of Idaho's resources.

Recreation has become a dominant industry in many areas. White-water rafting, skiing, snowmobiling, hunting, fishing, boating, and hiking are now major parts of the Idaho economy and common Idaho pastimes.

Native Peoples and the FSP

Many of Idaho's native peoples have established tribal gaming enterprises over the last decade or so. The proceeds enhance their tribal interests and provide additional revenue for schools and other infrastructures. With gaming enterprises, tribal economies have improved significantly.

On the one hand, Idaho's tribal members come from some very independent and self-reliant stock. Freedom is an inherent native tradition. On the other hand, more than a century of federally imposed administrative tribal governments, coupled with abundant socialistic hand out programs have weakened many tribal member's liberty spirit. Idaho native populations might be naturally inclined to support the principles of the FSP, once they are shown a model other than socialism to follow.

Alternative Schooling

Home schooling is common in Idaho with some reasonable cooperation between public schools and home schoolers on extra-curricular activities. Many home schoolers teach their children completely without government involvement. Children between the ages of 7 and 15 are required to attend some form of schooling. The statutory requirement only specifies that they be "otherwise comparably instructed." There is no state-required testing, teacher qualifications, or obligation to divulge the nature of the home school program. Home schoolers do not have to inform the school district that they are home schooling, and case law has established the burden of proof is upon the district to prove that any home schooling does not meet the statutory requirements.

Charter schools began a few years ago in Idaho, in what is essentially a state-funded, private school program. Time will tell how long "private" charter schools can remain on public funds. They do, however, tend to provide more bang for the buck – or less bucks – giving public schools much needed competition.

Vaccines

Like other states, Idaho has an active vaccination program. While most of the public literature portrays vaccinations as mandatory for school age and under children, it is a voluntary program. Exemption from the otherwise "required" vaccination of public and private school children is possible when a signed statement is filed, stating life or health endangering circumstances, religious or other objections.

Climate and Geography

Idaho has a wide variety of climates, terrain, and regions.

Central Idaho is largely a rugged mountain country that separates the other regions of Idaho. A two-lane highway passes through its western side, connecting northern and southern Idaho. At its core is a vast wilderness that is largely unroaded because of the terrain. Several major rivers have carved the deep canyons of Central Idaho where mostly small towns and rural settings are predominate. Climate varies with the elevation, from the high country covered with snow until July, to river bottoms and canyons that provide a "banana belt" and good gardening opportunities.

Northern Idaho is a mix of mountains, valleys, and prairies. Warm summers and moderate winters are common at the lower elevations. Climate is influenced more often by coastal weather than the central prairies. Couer d'Alene is the major city in North Idaho, which is dotted with many medium to smaller towns.

Southern Idaho contains the majority of Idaho's population and its political, economic, and industrial base. The Treasure Valley around the greater Boise area has a climate with hot summers and moderate winters. Urban and suburban development along the Snake River is surrounded by active agricultural production.

Eastern Idaho is a mix of high desert, mountains, and agriculturally developed prairies. Several eastern cities provide urban living opportunities, with many medium to small communities scattered across the mostly open terrain.

Idaho provides a vast array of rural living opportunities. High mountains, river valleys and canyons, the southern and eastern desert areas, the prairies and plains, offer many diverse choices for rurally inclined "Porcupines."

Economic Opportunities

Idaho ranks number one on both the FSP's projected jobs-growth analysis, and their economic freedom index. Contrary to the FSP's listing, Idaho does have a port in Lewiston. Although not a deep-water port for the larger ocean going vessels, many commercial products are barged up and down the Snake and Columbia Rivers. Rail service is available throughout Idaho. Idaho shares a short border with Canada and has two ports of entry.

Many businesses have relocated to Idaho because of lower taxes and less regulations when compared to other states. With some Porcupine influence, Idaho could improve this trend and become a gleaming example of a broad-based free-market economy.

Land-Use, Regulations, Building Codes and Federalism

Idaho is straddling the fence when it comes to land-use regulations and building codes. The forces of socialism and federalism have imposed active land-use strategies and construction requirements in most urban and suburban areas. The extent of the regulatory controls depends on how developed the area is. All counties have some form of building code on the books, but many, especially the rural counties, have lax enforcement of the code. Generally the farther you get from pavement the less regulation there is.

On the one hand, the wheels of social control have been turning in Idaho; on the other hand, socialism's wheels seem to be stuck in the ditch. For example, no contractor's license is required to build houses commercially, but you are required to get a landscapers license to plant shrubbery or install a lawn sprinkler system on the same house.

Many of the rural counties had building codes forced on them by FEMA, through federal flood insurance requirements. Similar federal back-door mandates are establishing citizen-tracking systems under the guise that emergency responders need a rural location identification system. The RIN or Rural Identification Number has been imposed on most rural Idahoans and is also conveniently useful for the construction of databases for citizen tracking and property mapping.

There are many other land-use and regulatory issues on the table that could be positively resolved by a herd of Porcupines. Road closures on public lands, "endangered" predator re-introduction, superfund sites, and environmental regulations are among the issues being imposed on Idaho by the federal government.

The Constitutional Defense Council

The Idaho Legislature has already paved the way for the Free State's plan to "finally negotiate directly with the federal government for appropriate political autonomy."

Under statute (Idaho Code 67-6301), the Constitutional Defense Council, which consists of the Governor, the President of the Senate, the Speaker of the House, and the Attorney General exists for the purpose of "restoring, maintaining and advancing the sovereignty and authority over issues that affect this state and the well-being of its citizens." Meetings of the council may be called by any member of the council, and may examine and challenge by legal action, legislation, or any other legal means: Federal mandates; Court rulings; The authority granted to, or assumed by, the federal government; Laws, regulations and practices of the federal government; And any other activity that is deemed appropriate by the council. The council may hire legal counsel and may utilize staff and resources within state government for these purposes.

Once enough Porcupines assume a majority of the offices which make up the Constitutional Defense Council, Idaho can begin to rein in the federal government.

The Case for Idaho

Consider the alternatives. If you're going to live somewhere, climate is important. It's easy to theorize about the relative importance of climate from an office in Florida or a house in California, but how many FSP Porcupines realistically want to hole up in Wyoming or the Dakotas for a high-plains winter? How many would be able to brave a harsh Alaskan winter and still be there in the spring? FSP meetings may not be well attended come February, when the gas lines in your car are frozen and the motor oil is thicker than grease.

If you want to attract a following it needs to be attractive for the long haul. A free state is not a one-year project. A cool but not too-cold Idaho canyon like the Clearwater, the Snake, or the Salmon might be more preferable in January than say, Bismarck ND.

And just what is the natural resource base of say, New Hampshire? How do free-staters plan to build a free-market export economy? Maple Syrup and hardwood flooring? Idaho already has diverse and productive natural resources in greater quantity than all the eastern state candidates combined. It also has the best economic prognosis according to the FSP's data.

The federal Constitution only authorizes federal ownership of lands within a state for four specific types of military purposes and other needful buildings. Once this fact becomes more widely known, and the federal usurpation of two-thirds of Idaho is properly challenged by 20,000 Porcupines (and a few more locals), we can "finally negotiate directly with the federal government for appropriate political autonomy." That's a lot of Idaho to build a free state with.

The political climate of Idaho is ripe for positive change. The republican majority in the legislature has upset much of the electorate by repealing a thrice-passed term limits law. The democrats are nearly DOA, and have been for years. The libertarians have made record progress and the Constitution Party is alive and well. That doesn't mean there aren't also a lot of lawyers, lobbyists, and socialists eager to maintain business as usual.

Let's get real. How many liberty-loving westerners would actually cross the Mississippi River to live? Easterners may like it there, but I don't think many westerners could call it home – even if we were the government. I've never been there, but I'll bet "rural" Vermont looks a lot more like "suburban" Idaho with deciduous trees. Size matters. And population density too.

Easterners and westerners are two different breeds of people. Are there only 20,000 liberty-oriented activists left in America? Eastern Porcupines would certainly be welcome out west, but what about a free state east and a free state west? We could alternate our annual free state convention and compare notes.

In all fairness there are a lot of good things that can be said about Montana as a choice for the FSP. Wyoming? Maybe. But Idaho, formerly known as the gem state, would make a great free state. I like it already: Idaho, "The Free State."

Statistical Analysis of the Free State Project Vote Count

6507 Jester Blvd. Suite 511

Austin, Texas 78726 USA

Voice: 512-219-0302

Fax: 512-219-0402

email: inquiry@ebenchmarks.com


Statistical Analysis of the Free State Project Vote Count

Alan R. Weiss, Chairman and CEO of Synchromesh Computing and ECL, LLC


Synchromesh Computing

 

 

Statistically, the following charts show various breakdowns based on self-reported demographics collected during the voting. Note that many of these independent-minded people chose to not reveal any demographic information, but 1663 people entered in at least their age and 1642 entered in their education levels.

 

Chart 1: Self-Identified Gender of Participants

As you can see, the Free State Project Membership is comprised overwhelmingly self-identified as males, which certainly matches the demographics of the Libertarians Party. However, it also matches involvement in politics in general, so there is nothing particularly Earth-shattering in all this.

We wanted to track whether or not people were voting for their own state, a state next door to them (we called that "same region"), in the same compass point (a western state not adjacent but still "western", for example), or people voting for a state completely outside their current location.

Chart 2: Voting by Region. We figured out their current location by their return address.

This result is a little biased towards larger population states, but nevertheless does show that a fair number of people did not mind moving to a state far away from their current state, region, or even compass point. To track gender against region, we found that they were roughly equal in being flexible enough to want to move to far-off places:

 

Chose Region 1

Chose Region 2

Chose Region 3

Chose Region 4

Female

8.2%

5.9%

34.4%

51.6%

Male

7.9%

8.1%

31.1%

52.9%

Table 2: Did Females Choose Differently Than Males? No.

Chart 3: Ages of Free State Project Voters

As you can see, most FSP members are skewed towards the younger side, with fully 75% being under age 50, and most of them being working age. It has been claimed that FSP people might be burdens on the welfare system of the selected state, but if they are they won't be taking old age benefits from New Hampshire. To check and see if this were the case, as best we could we tried to calculate a number of income related statistics:

Chart 4: Current Income by the Numbers

Not many FSP members currently make over $200,000 (as with the rest of society), but 1290 self-reported being above $20,000. In general, the FSP is comprised of middle and working class people, not rich for the most part (and, given marginal cumulative tax rates, including federal, state, local, property, school, and other taxes, it cannot be said that people making $200,000 to $300,000 are rich, either). The following chart compares income to education, and there are no surprises here: the greater the education level, the greater the income:

Chart 5: Income and Education

Chart 6: Age and Income. The Older, the Wealthier. Any surprises here?

A surprising number are not going to wait until 20,000 members join the Free State Project and choose to move to New Hampshire:

Chart 5: When Will They Move? Sooner than you think!

Some states were openly concerned about a population explosion. In one particularly paranoid and therefore humorous editorial in Vermont by Michael Patno, he expressed the opinion that about 4 people would move to Vermont for every Free State Project member (never mind that Vermont was not chosen - he was concerned that it might be). He thought that this would amount to a huge influx of 80,000 "new Vermonters."

Chart 6: Most are just moving themselves, or with one other person

 

Breaking down the voters who selected New Hampshire, we find that, out of the number of people who selected it first, most were very well educated with at least some college, if not more. In other words, hardly anyone who had a less than a high school diploma picked New Hampshire for their top selection - or even in their top five.

Chart 7: How Educated Were the Selectors Of New Hampshire?

Chart 8: 38% Are either Professional/Scientific/Technical or in Information Workers. 18% declared "Other"

We believe that a significant number of "Others" are actually students or retired people. The FSP Members have a breadth of talent, but the New Hampshire, being the closest state to a significant high technology area (in this case, Boston/Route 128), probably had a lot to do with it winning. Jobs and job prospects apparently trumped many other concerns.

Conclusion

The Members of the Free State Project have spoken, and rather clearly at that, in their selection of New Hampshire as The Free State. It may be the case that this particular project spawns a second effort to select a western state (or even a western province of Canada) as a relocation settlement.

If this occurs, it will not be due to any fraud or abuse of the process during voting, but rather because some liberty-minded individuals decide, quite simply, they prefer a western environment to establish a new libertarian society. If so, Synchromesh Analysts would be honored to again conduct the vote (if there is one) and certify the results.

Liberty expanding across the land ... who could argue against that? Those that would argue against it, would do themselves a favor in questioning why one would.

Ballot Subcommittee Report

Ballot Subcommittee Report for the Free State Project

Jason Sorens, Robert Hawes, Amanda Maxwell

May 15, 2003, revised July 7, 2003

Following are the ballot subcommittee's proposals for the state vote procedures for the Free State Project.

Attached: sample ballot

Timeline

The deadline for people to sign up and enjoy the right to participate in the vote is August 15. The ballot mailing will be put together immediately (printed and stuffed, at least 5,100 copies; labels printed for existing members), and independent vote counters will be chosen. The ballots will be mailed out to all existing members on July 20. As new members come in they will have ballots mailed to them. If 5,000 members will not have been reached by the time of the deadline for signing up, the deadline shall be extended. After the deadline, all members will have three weeks - until September 8 - to send in their ballots. Ballots may be sent in by postal mail or as scanned images attached to e-mail and clearly marked in the subject heading as Free State Project ballots. Ballots must be received by the vote counters before the end of this three week period in order to be counted. Ballots may be sent in as soon as they are received. The ballots will be promptly placed on the website for public viewing, by member number only, so that they remain anonymous but can be checked by each voter. There is one week in which to challenge the results on the basis that one's ballot has not been included or has been miscounted. At the end of this week-long period (September 15), the winning state shall be announced.

Immediately after the Vote

Anyone who has not cast a ballot or indicated an intentional abstention by September 15 shall be removed from the membership rolls immediately. Anyone who has opted out of the winning state shall be removed from the membership rolls immediately. However, both groups of people should be contacted as soon as possible with letters encouraging them to sign up again for the state that has been chosen.

Design of Ballot

The ballot shall be designed with the member number and name stamped on top. The middle of the ballot shall have ten lines for ranking the ten states under consideration, and brief instructions on filling them out, as follows: "Rank the states under consideration for the Free State Project, in order from top to bottom. These are the states to be ranked: Alaska, Delaware, Idaho, Maine, Montana, New Hampshire, North Dakota, South Dakota, Vermont, Wyoming. Fill in your ranking next to each one: '1' for a first-place vote, '2' for second place, and so on, until you reach '10' for your least favorite state. If you wish to indicate a tie, fill in the same number for two or more states." Below the ranking section, there shall be an affidavit reading as follows, "I hereby certify that I am a signer of the Free State Project Statement of Intent, that I am at least 18 years of age, and that I cast this ballot in good faith. I understand that casting a fraudulent or falsified ballot will render me subject to civil penalties." Each member shall be required to sign and date this affidavit in order to have his or her ballot counted. In addition, each member shall be requested to obtain the signature of a notary public, and a line on the ballot shall be provided for this purpose. If a voter is unable to notarize the ballot, he or she may instead include a photocopy of one of the following documents showing his or her name: utility bill, driver's license, passport, university identification, library card. If a voter is unable to verify his or her identity in either manner, he or she must include a phone number on the ballot (a line shall be provided for this purpose), so that a volunteer from the Free State Project may contact the voter and authenticate.

Additional Materials in Ballot Mailing

The ballot mailing shall have a cover letter, explaining the timeline, requirements, and voting method (Simple Condorcet, also called Simpson). The cover letter shall also describe the other materials in the mailing and give an address, email address, and phone number for questions relating to the ballot. The Free State Project shall make available a toll-free number for this purpose. The mailing shall also contain advocacy reports for each of the 10 states under consideration. Each report shall be one page in length, front and back, and unless otherwise specified, in 11-point Times New Roman font with a bold, centered title. Each report shall be vetted by the Research Committee for factual accuracy and logical argument before inclusion in the mailing. Supporters of each state shall be encouraged to collaborate on production of pithy yet effective reports well in advance of the vote. Each working group will provided with an e-mail list and should elect a group leader who will be responsible for submitting the final report. The mailing shall contain an addressed envelope for return of the ballot to the independent vote-counting firm (described below). The mailing may contain a separate envelope addressed to the FSP itself for monetary contributions to cover the cost of the vote.

Vote Counters and Reporting of Results

The services of a reputable election auditing firm will be secured to count the ballots. The vote counters shall tabulate the ballots in the following format in Microsoft Excel '97 or 2000:

	AK  DE  ID  ME  MT  NH  ND  SD  VT  WY  #

Where beneath each column is placed the number of the rank on the ballot: 1 for first place, 10 for last place; the final column "#" shall contain the member # of the person who cast the ballot. The spreadsheet will generate Condorcet tables, including one on one comparisons for all states in terms of votes for and against, and defeats and victories. The completed spreadsheet, both all member ballots and all Condorcet tables and comparisons, shall be posted to the website by midnight of the deadline for sending in ballots (September 8). All members shall be strongly encouraged to write down and remember their member numbers and then check to the website to ensure that their ballots have been counted correctly.

A Critical Moment

FSP Friends and Members: A Critical Moment

Tuesday, 8 July 2003

Well, gang, the moment of the vote is upon us. And while we're willing to do all the work involved in this historic vote to choose the Free State, we absolutely need your help RIGHT NOW with one thing: funding. Getting 5000 ballot packages printed and mailed through a professional mailing house will cost approximately $6000. Getting a respected third-party firm to handle the vote-counting process is another necessary expense - that's another $2000.

The whole process will thus require approximately $8000. Those of you who've read our 2nd quarter report know that we had $8000 in the bank as of June 20, not counting outstanding obligations, such as reimbursement for speakers at the Grand Western and New Hampshire Getaway conferences, and printing costs for outreach materials. The conferences were definitely worth the money, as was our advertising, as you can see by the incredible media coverage we've gotten lately.

But last week, our Paypal debit card number was stolen, and $2000 in charges were racked up by the thief. We are working with Paypal to get that money back, but at this critical moment we are suddenly out of needed funds.

The long and short of it is that right now, we have access to $2500. That means we need to raise at least $5500 by July 20, when we send out the ballots. That sounds like a lot, but we are a sizeable organization now, and now more than ever, we need your help.

If each of you contributed $25, $50, or $100, we would have enough to do this all-important voting process right. You can send a check or money order to our address at Free State Project, Inc., 565 College Drive Suite #C-160, Henderson, NV 89015, or contribute online via Paypal (credit card of direct bank transfer) at this address.

For more details on the vote, please check out the description of the process here.

For more information on what the FSP has accomplished lately, check out News.

Thanks for your support! And please act quickly. The FSP's long-term financial outlook is great, but we are now in the middle of a cash crunch.

Jason Sorens, President
Free State Project

Free State Project Vote Count, Certification Process, and Results

6507 Jester Blvd. Suite 511

Austin, Texas 78726 USA

Voice: 512-219-0302

Fax: 512-219-0402

email: inquiry@ebenchmarks.com


 

Free State Project Vote Count, Certification Process, and Results

Alan R. Weiss, Chairman and CEO of Synchromesh Computing and ECL, LLC


Synchromesh Computing

Free State Project Vote Count , Certification Process, and Results

Background

Its actually an interesting problem: how do you assure that a healthy, contentious, very public vote of a private organization dedicated to liberty and freedom goes smoothly? How do you make sure that all the votes are counted according to a publicly-available process, that the votes are counted fairly and honestly, and that the entire process can be certifiable (that is to say, repeatable and trustworthy)? Can you establish the creation of free-market solutions to what was previously the purview of Government (often-times poorly), counting votes?

When ECL volunteered to create a "certifiable process" for counting The Free State Project's votes, Free State President and Founder Jason Sorens asked the Author, innocently enough, if we'd also be willing to count the ballots. We agreed, and together we decided to make history.

ECL, the EEMBC Certification Laboratories, has had over 5 years of experience creating and executing benchmark certifications for microprocessors, digital signal processors, and micrcontrollers as well as a operating systems and software tools. As the certification company for an industry-standard consortium of almost 60 semiconductor and software companies, all ardent competitors to each other, we have the sort of background you need to be able to create certifiable processes. With a rigorous background in engineering, a charter and mission explicitly stating fairness and honesty, trustworthiness and equality of treatment, ECL has successfully certified hundreds of benchmark scores. In the semiconductor industry, the results of benchmarking can, at times, be worth literally hundreds of millions of dollars in sales, so a lack of guile is considered necessary, to say the least. Companies, and individuals, trust ECL, and for our part we have never had our fairness questioned or in dispute.

The first step, obviously, would be to establish a Certifiable Process. If you want to know who won, however, you can jump to Page 5 and find out.


 

Creating the Certifiable Process - and the Results of the Process

The key would be to write up a process that included the following attributes, and publish that on the Free State Project website. The membership would have to "buy in" and trust it.

Repeatable

 

The Vote Count and Tally must be repeatable to a level of only 2 defects in the entire vote count. Furthermore, the actual ballots will be preserved for the future so that a vote count can be done at any time.

 

During ECL's Quality Assurance procedures, we sampled over 600 ballots and found only one, very minor error (which was immediately corrected). We estimated that there might be as many as five errors in the vote count, which we knew would not affect the outcome (but each defect would, of course, have to be corrected immediately).

 

In fact, our defect count showed that, after completing voting, there were essentially no defects in the vote count. After posting the double-checked database to the FSP website (to allow individuals to verify their own vote count once they entered in their FSP member number and their last name), not a single person contact ECL or the FSP, and reported that their vote was counted incorrectly.

Safe

 

ECL will make copies of all votes, and also scan them, providing a permanent record.  Copies will be stored both on-site and off-site.  ECL's physical security system is very secure, and has passed scrutiny of companies that have billions of dollars at stake. 

 

In practice, we tried very hard to quantify the amount of work required to:

 

a.) open the envelope or retrieve the fax, or email.

b.) input the vote itself

c.) input the demographic information

d.) calculate and process any money donated (in fact, ECL processed over $13,000 and turned every federal reserve note, check, money order, silver and gold warehouse receipt, and other form of currency to the Free State Project).

We found that we could process a ballot at a rate of 1 per 2 1/2 minutes, but that scanning each and every ballot would add at least 5 minutes to the process. We decided, in consultation with the FSP Board of Directors, to instead do the following:

 

a.) Make a physical photocopy of each ballot, and store them off-site.

b.) Commit the spreadsheet database where votes were recorded to a Concurrent Version System (CVS) often used in software engineering, so that versions of the spreadsheet could be retrieved at any time.

c.) Back up the data every day to a second machine (a server), and burn a CD-ROM as well every two days.

 

If anyone questioned their vote, we'd have at least five copies (two paper, three electronic) and could always scan and send via email their ballot at the time of challenge. In practice, this was never required.

 

Checkpoints of the vote count showed a complete absence of defects as well, and we could retrieve any arbitrary set of ballots, double-check them, and calculate any defects. There were none, which we attribute both to good processes as well as the diligence of our ECL Free State Project Coordinator Erin Decatur Silkenson, a dedicated worker with a Bachelors Degree in Economics from Southwestern University in Georgetown, Texas. Erin was used to dealing with large amounts of data. Background checks on Erin showed she was reliable, dedicated, and amazingly tolerant of people's curious penchant for wanting to convey their opinions to the Free State Project itself by somehow forwarding it, along with their votes and occasionally money, to ECL.

Auditable. 

 

At any time, the FSP Directors (or invited guests) can statistically sample the vote count themselves, and at any time the FSP can request a list of who has voted.  A statistical sample should yield at most 1 error in 2500 votes.  In addition, we will send all of the ballots to the FSP.  ECL will do a cross-check after they have audited and compare our results.  The results must match 100%. ECL will employ technology to make sure the ballots we have sent to the FSP are the same as the ones we counted.

 

ECL only received one request to come audit the vote count, and that person (also located in Central Texas) decided that she was too busy to actually come watch us open envelopes and enter text into the spreadsheet. The best way to audit is to have each member be able to double-check their own votes online after voting was completed, and FSP Information Services expert Matt Cheselka put the database online with alacrity after ECL finished the final vote tally and quality assurance procedure, certifying the vote.

 

Fair and Honest

 

Each ECL staff member having access to the votes (and it will only be two people) will sign affidavits and have them notarized of our vote count, honesty, and that we followed this CP.

 

Only two people actually had access to the votes, the spreadsheets, and the money that came in: Erin, and ECL / Synchromesh Computing Chairman and CEO Alan R. Weiss. Neither Erin, who is not a member of the FSP, nor myself (who joined rather late in the Project's history) had any axes to grind, and by profession both of us were intensely interested in what could only be described as "the truth." Economics is a profession that rests on hard data, and Benchmarking Certification by definition is designed to ward off corruption and report "the real results." Erin's family was from Ohio and New York, and Alan, born in NYC but raised in California, moved to Austin Texas 11 years ago. None of those states were on the selection list, and as Alan put it in a message to the Free State Project membership, "all y'all look alike - all cold weather states!"


 

Certification Granted

ECL/Synchromesh Computing hereby certifies the results of the Free State Project balloting and voting process as fairly conducted, results honestly polled, providing fair access to FSP members, and repeatable under all circumstances.

 

By This Seal, ECL Certifies the Vote Count as Accurate

 

Balloting Process, Timetables, and Turnout

If there was a flaw in the process, it was that ballots were mailed late to many members (being sent via US Postal Service Third Class instead of First Class from Henderson, Nevada). Combined with other delays, it truncated the voting time period by a couple of weeks, which in theory should not have mattered a great deal since the voting interval was still over a month. In practice, it caused some confusion, and furthermore the announcement schedule was fixed as a hard and fast end-date for Press relations reasons.

ECL was concerned that if a lot of members waited till the very last minute, the incoming flood would have proved to be uncertifiable given a "hard stop" date. In actuality, this was avoided because about half the members voted (reducing the incoming flow considerably) and members reacted with (mostly) timely responses.

Ballots were mailed out, and could be returned via US Mail Postal Express, Federal Express, Airborne Express, UPS, or other common carrier. The number of ballots returned by these means, costing each member a few dollars each, was staggering - well over 200 came in that way, almost 1/10th of the received vote. This showed, clearly, that of those that voted, they really cared about making sure their vote came in on time, and was counted. Because of the initial ballot dissemination snafu's, ECL decided to accept a fax of the ballot, or an Adobe Acrobat (tm) .PDF file. Later, ECL agreed to accept a JPEG file as well. In practice, about 1/10th of the ballots came in using these electronic methods (and towards the end, a higher percentage.

5000 ballots were ultimately mailed to FSP members, and ECL's final count of 2388 constitutes a return of 47.7%. While its tempting to be depressed about that, we believe the following factors are important to keep in mind, observationally:

·         A government-sponsored vote (for example, an election or propositions) that saw almost a 50% turnout would be considered extremely newsworthy and be deemed a "very successful election."

·         The Free State Project has been in existence for awhile, and doubtlessly a number of people had moved, didn't leave a forwarding address, or otherwise lost contact with the FSP.

·         A certain percentage of people, realizing that signing up is fairly easy (although they had to make a Pledge), voting was quite another matter and might constitute even more of "a contract." This fear of really committing is to be expected in any movement that asks its members to sell their home, quit their jobs, pick up their lives, and move them to a state that may be quite alien or foreign to them and then "get to work" setting their lives back up as well as working for liberty and freedom and democracy. Given the magnitude of the basic decision, it is utterly astonishing that almost 50% even returned their ballots at all.

·         The average dollar figure donated to the FSP was over $5 per voter, and would have been much higher had the FSP not encouraged people to fax or email in their vote (of course, the primary purpose of the vote was not fundraising, but rather to vote. ECL fully concurred that was most important). Further, the number of people calling and sending email to ECL to verify that their votes were cast and recorded was impressive, as were the number of votes returned by expensive common carrier rather than simply the US Postal Service regular first class mail. Those that voted, were very serious about their voting and it can be said with clarity that no one took it lightly.

The Winners and the Statistics

The answer to "which state is the Free State" is New Hampshire. New Hampshire not only beat 2nd place Wyoming by over 250 votes using the Condorcet Method, it also won if you just weighed "the number of first place votes granted to a state."

As Jason Sorens commented, "One interesting factoid is that preferences are very stable and
"well-behaved": not only is there a Condorcet winner over the entire 10 candidates, but if you eliminate the Condorcet winner sequentially, there is a Condorcet winner at each iteration, yielding the final ranking:

  1. New Hampshire
  2. Wyoming
  3. Montana
  4. Idaho
  5. Alaska
  6. Maine
  7. Vermont
  8. Delaware
  9. South Dakota
  10. North Dakota

As the following table shows, New Hampshire received 251 more first place votes, and 15 more 2nd place votes, than runner-up Wyoming.


 

 

State

AK

DE

ID

MT

ND

NH

ME

SD

VT

WY

# of 1st's

253

284

238

242

24

749

118

32

97

498

# of 2nd's

250

231

247

391

38

341

257

79

241

326

Table 1: Total Number of First and Second Place Votes by State

 

The total number of first and second place votes is greater than the total vote count because the FSP allowed people to vote for more than one first or second (or any place) entry. Many people, for example, gave a particular state a "one" and gave two or more states a "two", and sometimes gave many states a "ten" (indicating no interest at all in selecting that state).

 

Interestingly, it appears that the so-called "western Libertarians" divided their votes between Wyoming, Montana, Idaho, and Alaska, leaving the so-called "eastern Libertarians", who were much more unified in their first selection, clear access to win with their favorite, New Hampshire. If you combine, for example, the first place votes of Montana and Wyoming, you get 242 + 498 = 740, which would not have been enough to topple New Hampshire. But if you notice the spread between Idaho, Montana, and Alaska, it is much closer than the spread between New Hampshire and the next most popular eastern state, Maine. Montana seemed to be a very popular 2nd place choice, beating even New Hampshire as the second-favorite state. Clearly the industriousness, organization, and marketing of New Hampshire had some effect, though, because it won, and it was also a popular second place choice, even amongst so-called "western Libertarians."

 

Conclusion

The Members of the Free State Project have spoken, and rather clearly at that, in their selection of New Hampshire as The Free State. It may be the case that this particular project spawns a second effort to select a western state (or even a western province of Canada) as a relocation settlement.

If this occurs, it will not be due to any fraud or abuse of the process during voting, but rather because some liberty-minded individuals decide, quite simply, they prefer a western environment to establish a new libertarian society. If so, Synchromesh Analysts would be honored to again conduct the vote (if there is one) and certify the results.

Liberty expanding across the land ... who could argue against that? Those that would argue against it, would do themselves a favor in questioning why one would.

 

 

For more statistics, refer to the Statistical Analysis White Paper. We removed that from this Paper because some people were having difficulties downloading a very large file.

 

State Report WY 5: Keith's Tour of Wyoming

Keith's Tour of Wyoming

From the 19th of July to the 28th of July 2003, I toured Colorado, Wyoming, and South Dakota. I spend the majority of my time in Wyoming and this report chronicles my time in that state. Overall, I finished the tour thinking that Wyoming is an even stronger candidate state than I had previously thought. I know most Free State Project members are unable to take a tour of Wyoming but I hope you learn something new about the state from my travels.

July 19th – Ft. Collins, CO

  • There are decent looking mountains right next to the city.
  • The city features a nice outdoor walking mall just like Boulder, CO and Burlington, VT.
  • Large companies like HP and factories are just a few minutes off the Interstate.
  • Colorado State University is huge.
  • There are other local universities like the University of Northern Colorado and the University of Colorado.
  • It takes just over 30 minutes to go from Ft. Collins, CO to Cheyenne, WY (going around 80 mph, potentially you could drive faster but it might not be recommended) but it would take a little longer too go from downtown Cheyenne to downtown Ft. Collins.
  • The consensus opinion was that you could work in Ft. Collins and live in Cheyenne and that people already do it.
  • However, I was cautioned that the Interstate is closed for a handful of days a year because of wind and the snow drifts it can cause.
  • It takes just over 90 minutes to get to the Denver Airport from Cheyenne.
  • In Colorado, people drive fast and it is not unusual for the flow of the traffic to be 85 mph.
  • In Wyoming, people are more likely to drive around 70-80 mph (the speed limit is 75).
  • I'm not sure if this is because there is very little stress in Wyoming or if it's just so magical that people slow down to take in all of the wonders.

July 20th – Cheyenne, WY

  • In Wyoming, a "Weigh Station" is called a "Port of Entree".
  • The first thing I saw as I crossed the border into Wyoming was a huge Polaris store.
  • The second thing I saw is a huge camping/RV community.
  • I could not figure out why Cheyenne even has an airport if the Denver airport is just 90 minutes away.
  • Lots of I-25 and I-80 Interstates exits mean that is takes very little time to travel the city.
  • Very friendly people.
  • Tons of trees everywhere.
  • Actually, all of Wyoming's towns (that I visited) are filled with trees.
  • There are museums everywhere (most of Wyoming has lots of museums because of the tourism trade).
  • Parking is allowed on most downtown roads for two hours for free.
  • Cheyenne has at least two same-day dry cleaners.
  • Over half the vehicles on the road were cars (but some Wyoming towns had more "other vehicles" than cars).
  • I entered the Cheyenne Air Force base just to look around (I am military so it was easy to get in) and on my way out (during rush hour) I almost hit a deer.

    Wyoming Taxpayer Association

  • I met with Michael of the Wyoming Taxpayer Association.
  • This is a group with many corporate members and some regular-folk members.
  • The group is non-partisan and the group's website describes it pretty nicely.
  • Michael is a very nice guy and a great people person.
  • He once had Dave Dawson speak at one of the Wyoming Taxpayer Association functions.
  • He fought against the Cigarette tax increase and said Wyoming did not need the money.
  • He said there is some popular support to lower Wyoming's already very low property tax.
  • He said that Wyomingites pay less taxes on average, than people from any other state, except Alaska.
  • He reminded me that some young people consider Wyoming boring.
  • I asked him about the winters in Cheyenne and he said the roads do not ice over.
  • I asked him about Wyoming's least populated county (Niobrara, with around 2,200 people) and he said it would love to have us (great news Zack).
  • He told me that people in Wyoming think government stops at their front door and some would like it to stop even sooner.
  • He summed it up by saying that people in Wyoming have a "live and let live" attitude and don't care about your personal life.

    The Cheyenne Paper

  • I read the Cheyenne newspaper while in town and found some interesting information.
  • The University of Wyoming does not even have a track and field facility; they have to use the high school's.
  • The Indian Reservation is building a new 30,000 square-foot bingo casino.
  • The weather report for Cheyenne and other cities:

    City Mon
    (Hi/Lo)
    Tues
    (Hi/Lo)
    Wed
    (Hi/Lo)
    Thu
    (Hi/Lo)
    Fri
    (Hi/Lo)
    Comments
    Cheyenne, WY 91/62 89/60 90/60 88/59 88/58 Normal is 81/55
    Anchorage, AK 67/54 65/53       This is summer weather?
    Portland, ME 72/63 78/64        
    Bismarck, ND 83/56 87/61        
    Wilmington, DE 88/71 82/69        
    Rapid City, SD 91/62 90/61        
    Billings, MT 95/63 96/67        
    Boise, ID 102/72 103/68        
    NH ? ?       The paper did have Boston
    VT ? ?        

July 21st – Torrington, WY

  • The city is 75 minutes from Cheyenne.
  • The drive between the two cities consisted of hills, bluffs, rock formations, farmland, and grassland.
  • The sign said that Torrington has 5,700+ people. And I counted seven hotels.
  • The hotel that I stayed in charges $25 per night (or $120 per week), after tax.
  • That means someone could stay there for around $500 per month and get a hotel room, continental breakfast, maid service, cable, local calls, water, and electricity.
  • The hotel offered no discounts and charged me one dollar less for paying with cash.
  • It is a locally owned hotel and the owner accidentally charged me a dollar extra so he walked to my room to give me the dollar.
  • Scottsbluff, NE is 35 minutes away.
  • Scottsbluff has everything you would expert from a town its size including: Super Walmart, mall, zoo, gentleman's club, and a Radio Shack.
  • Scottsbluff National Monument and Chimney Rock are just outside of Scottsbluff, NE. They are both amazing places with excellent trails that go all the way to the top of Scottsbluff National Monument.
  • I think Torrington has extra jobs because I noticed illegal aliens in town.
  • Scottsbluff, Gering, and Mitchell (5 minutes from Torrington) also have jobs and the roads are easy to drive all winter long.
  • The only problem is that Nebraska has an income tax (like Idaho, Montana, Maine, Vermont, and Delaware).
  • Houses are very inexpensive in Torrington. Decent safe houses in town cost $45,000.
  • I was looking at property and I noticed 40 acres (13 miles from town) with a well, electric, and phone lines advertised for $45,000.
  • Torrington gets very little snow but has high humidity in the summer. I did not feel hot, though, because of the breeze.
  • I am seriously thinking about moving to Torrington if Wyoming is picked.
  • Torrington seems to be a farm town with sugar beets, wheat, corn, and beans being the major crops.
  • There is also a community college in Torrington (and Cheyenne, and Casper, and Sheridan...)
  • Community colleges are great because students get more one-on-one time than at universities, for about 1/2 to 1/4 the price.

July 22nd – Guernsey, WY

  • Guernsey is a nice little town of around 1,100 people.
  • People do not need to lock their house doors; some people still leave their keys in the ignition and the car doors unlocked.
  • This town has a 1,000 yard shooting range.
  • Guernsey is a beautiful small town with both public and private miniature Black Hills all around the town.
  • I went in the Guernsey State Park and met a nice couple from CO that goes their to look for rocks.
  • They told me all about Wyoming and its rock history and all kinds of other stuff.
  • They even gave me this special type of rock that they had just found.
  • They said it was valuable outside of Wyoming and that it would look great if I shined it up (I was a little confused).
  • They said that there is a lake a few miles away that is used by people with wave runners from all over the West.
  • The state park has nice canyon walls that are right next to the road (a little too close for comfort).
  • Guernsey has decent houses for around $40,000 and all of the houses are safe.
  • The charm of this town will stay in my memory for along time.
  • I was at a local diner and I saw a child helping his parents out (for some reason the parents were not charged with child abuse and violation of child labor laws :) .

  • I stayed with Mark Spungin, the President of the Wyoming State Shooting Association.
  • I do not want to describe his house very much but it had a nice garden with sunflowers (among other pretty plants) and would be a dream home for anyone that is crazy about guns.
  • Both he and his wife were extraordinarily nice.
  • Actually, I stayed in the Boston T Party suite :)
  • Mark had been on the town council before.
  • It was a local, non-partisan election and he could have won again but he wanted to be Mayor.
  • He ran for Mayor and did OK; ran for State House as a Libertarian Party member but didn't do very well.
  • He told me that a libertarian had been elected to his state House district before but that he did not get reelected.
  • Mark said that the gun laws in Wyoming are some of the best in the country (our research backs this up) and that there is not much discontent with them.
  • He said he likes the Free State Project and hopes it comes to Wyoming.
  • I asked him if any other state was better for the project and he said nope, Wyoming is the best.
  • Actually, a couple of times he said "we" like he was a part of the FSP (it seems like he is part of the project, at least in his heart).
  • He thinks that large cities are breeding grounds for big government.
  • I asked him about the tax situation in Wyoming and he said that he only pays around $260 a year in property tax.
  • He said that if 2,000 of us joined the WSSA we would have massive power and if we were activists we might be able to change the gun laws.
  • He said that he thinks Wyoming would go for Vermont Carry.
  • He told me that in Wyoming they don't allow local cities to make gun laws so that no city can prevent you from carry open or concealed (if you have a permit).
  • He said that in Alaska local governments are allowed to make strict gun laws and that Anchorage's gun laws are more strict than the Alaska state laws.
  • He told me about Boston T Party's book, Molon Labe. It's a fictional tale about a group like the FSP moving to Wyoming and slowing changing the minds of the people, county by county.
  • I asked him about Wyoming's smallest county, Niobrara.
  • He did not think many people would want to live in that country, but that it would not be hard to influence the county.
  • I asked him about Hot Springs County and he said he liked that county and if he was not in Gurney, he might live there.
  • He told me a story about how some big government politicians tried to increase the size the Thermopolis's (the major city in Hot Springs County) government and they were all voted out in the next election.
  • He said you have to be honest with the people of Wyoming (State Senator Bruce Burns later said the same thing).
  • He told me that they don't have DUI checkpoints in Wyoming.
  • I asked him that if he likes the FSP so much, why doesn't he join.
  • He said he already lives in Wyoming.
  • He said that he is going to retire in 2004 so he will have more free time to be an activist.
  • He homeschooled his kids and I asked him about the homeschooling laws in Wyoming.
  • He said his family had no problems teaching his kids exactly what he wanted to teach them and that around 20 kids in his small town are homeschooled.
  • He said the Wyoming Highway Patrol only has around 166 members.
  • Right after I left, he and his wife headed off to go practice shooting for some national shooting completion.

  • His wife, Beverly Spungin, is an even a better shooter than he is (and a great cook), grew up in North Dakota.
  • She shared with me a couple bright spots of North Dakota: great soil, and fields & fields of sunflowers.
  • However, she did say that North Dakota was too flat for her.
  • She is the Vice President of the Wyoming State Shooting Association, the Secretary of the Wyoming Libertarian Party, and also a volunteer firefighter/EMT.
  • She said that they did not have a major snow storm last year until March and that they do not get much snow in Guernsey.

July 23rd – Douglas, Glenrock, and Casper WY

  • Douglas is a nice small town with beautiful mountain views.
  • I stopped in, got a car wash, ate lunch at a nice Chinese restaurant, and had a root beer float at A&W.
  • I saw a little motel for sale.
  • This would be a great place for FSP members to pay $300 per month and have a seasonal place to stay.
  • I noticed that there was a Douglas Motocross Speedway bingo parlor.
  • I asked the lady about it and she said they have non-profit bingo parlors all over the state and named Casper, Douglas, Torrington, and Gillette as examples.
  • Well, I guess that means Wyoming really does have casinos.

  • Glenrock was a nice town, and it too has beautiful mountain views.
  • I stopped at a city park that was nothing but a field with a variety of weeds, low brush, and cacti, and two massive rock formations.
  • I spent around 20 minutes chasing a group of 14 mule deer up the rock formation.
  • The was my first encounter with a group of mule deer.
  • They were quite loud to show their anger but continued to back up.
  • Eventually I chased them through barbed wire, up a hill, and into a valley.
  • In Wyoming, there is no one to keep you off the land and things like barbed wire don't work either; you are free to travel anywhere you can imagine.
  • State Senator Keith Goodenough said that some people live in Glenrock and work in Casper.
  • Glenrock is around 25 miles from Casper.

  • Casper is another great city.
  • Casper is right next to the mountains.
  • In fact, Casper Mountain and the other nearby mountains look notably better than the foothills and mountains of Ft. Collins, CO.
  • Houses cost a lot (unless you're from the Boston area or California) on the mountain and right next to the mountain, but are noticeably less in the parts of Casper that are not near the mountain.
  • Casper is where most of the Western trails meet, and then split off with some of them going to CA, ID, MT, and UT.
  • The people of Casper are regular people; this is not a town of yuppies.
  • I was told that the winter wind keeps housing prices down.
  • A lot of the houses have either boats or RVs in the yard.
  • I already knew that Casper, Cheyenne, and Rock Springs had off-track betting for the horse track in Evanston; however, I learned that the cities also have off-track betting from horse tracks around the country.

    State Senator Keith Goodenough

  • He is enough libertarian for people like us to call him a libertarian.
  • He described himself as 1/3 Democrat/Republican/Libertarian.
  • That seems to sell to the independent people of Wyoming because he started out in the House and moved to the Senate.
  • Keith is a man of the people, maybe it would be best to call him a Jeffersonian Democrat.
  • He supports lower taxes and more social freedoms.
  • He told me that the Democrats in Wyoming have a higher NRA score than the Republicans.
  • I do not know about local politicians but the Wyoming Congressional Delegation (all Republican) has the best Gun Owners of American record in the nation so I am guessing that both political parties have great gun records.
  • He said the people of Wyoming support medical marijuana.
  • In fact, he said that in 1992 the House voted on the issue and they voted overwhelmingly for medical marijuana, but the issue is hard to push in the Senate.
  • He said that it would pass if the issue were on the ballot.
  • He told me that the Native American's are winning the fight to get full gambling casinos on the Wind River Reservation.
  • He said that he wants us in Wyoming and could use us.
  • He also said that he wished us luck and wrote me a special email about how he enjoyed our meeting.
  • He said that he thought the elderly paid too much property tax. (Michael, the executive director of the Wyoming Taxpayer Association also told me this). The way I look at it, any tax cut that does not give money to people that do not pay taxes is a good tax cut. I am glad there is a movement in Wyoming to lower the property tax rates (even though they are already some of the lowest in the country).
  • I asked him if he thought another state would be more receptive and he did not think so.
  • I did not ask him, so this is just a wild guess – but I imagine him being a hippie in the 70s.
  • There are only 30 Senators in Wyoming and it is a big plus that one of them really likes us.
  • Keith is very nice and down to earth.
  • We were in the parking lot of the bar and this guy from Wisconsin asked for some gas money and Keith was very nice and calm with him and gave him $20.
  • Here is the signature line that Keith uses in his emails, "Wyoming Constitution...Article 1, Section 1: All power is inherent in the people, and all free governments are founded on their authority, and instituted for their peace, safety and happiness; for the advancement of these ends they have at all times an inalienable and indefeasible right to alter, reform or abolish the government in such manner as they may think proper."
  • Keith explained an interesting way that very few people could have a lot of control in Natrona County (the one with Casper).
  • Some of the measures have to be passed by 4 of the 6 communities in the county in order to go into effect.
  • However, Casper is the only city with more than a few thousand people.
  • A couple of the communities have around 500 people.
  • He explained that if we could move into 3 of the 6 communities and vote against passing these measures the whole county would have to kill the measures.
  • Likewise, if we moved in 4 of the 6 small communities we could get things passed that the city of Casper (with almost all of the county's populations) does not want passed.
  • I think that is a great tool and it certainly works to our advantage.

July 24th

  • I met with State Senator John Schiffer (R) of Kaycee, Wyoming.
  • His district covers all of Johnson County (with Buffalo and Kaycee being the main towns) and the southern part of Sheridan County.
  • He told me that term limits are real and they are going to start next election.
  • He bought me peach pie (yum) at a little restaurant in Kaycee (this is a very small town).
  • John said he would like the FSP to come to Wyoming because he thinks new ideas and discussions would be useful.
  • He is already a committee chairman, but might be set to become one of the Senate leaders. (He is already the VP of the Senate).
  • He is a rancher and is one of the few people I saw in Wyoming that looked like a cowboy. His shirt was torn and it looked like he had been working has ranch before our meeting.
  • He told me that Wyoming passed the recent cigarette tax increase because Wyoming has to produce a balanced budget every year and it was an easy way to balance the budget.
  • I told me why they did not just make cuts and he said they also made cuts to programs.
  • He said he did not agree to vote for the tax increase until a sunset provision was added to it.
  • I asked him why Wyoming was the least regulated state in the country and used the example of no acupuncture laws in Wyoming.
  • He said that it is called "fencing" and they try to keep that out of Wyoming.
  • He explained fencing as this: someone in one industry moves in and tries to enact tough laws to keep others out.
  • He said that they try to prevent such practices in Wyoming.
  • He told me that they have preemption laws for guns in Wyoming. This means that Wyoming towns cannot pass gun laws that are more strict than the state laws.
  • He said people would be willing to work with us issue by issue but it would be hard to hold a coalition together because people are very independent in Wyoming.
  • I asked him if there were any counties that would respond positively to our smaller government message.
  • He said every county would respond positively to it but explained that there are constituents for every program.
  • He said that he likes to hear what the people of his district think about the issues.
  • He said that he thought medical marijuana would pass as a ballot imitative.
  • He told me that his daughter moved to Portland, Maine but could not handle the winter there.
  • He said that the winter is much worse in Maine than in Wyoming.

July 25th

  • I met with State Senator Bruce Burns (R) of Sheridan, Wyoming.
  • He said that Montana is too big and spread out for the FSP to succeed in Montana.
  • He said that Wyoming already has one of the smallest governments.
  • He said the Democrats of Wyoming are like Republicans.
  • He said he likes the idea of the FSP but thinks the people and state of Wyoming already have so much in common with the FSP, that things would not change much in Wyoming.
  • He bought me lunch at a steak house in Sheridan.
  • He thought that we should pick Vermont.
  • He said it is the only state that elected a self-proclaimed socialist to the US House.
  • He said that we could make a huge national impact if we picked Vermont and changed its entire Congressional Delegation.
  • He pointed out that we would not make much impact with Wyoming's Congressional Delegation because they are already so inline with us (they are considered the most pro-gun by Gun Owner's of America and the most libertarian by the Republican Liberty Caucus, and Senator Michael Enzi is considered to be the most libertarian US Senator in the nation).
  • He did admit that Vermont has harsh winters.
  • I tried to explain why Wyoming and New Hampshire were leading states but he would not let up on this Vermont idea of his.
  • He said that a sizable minority of the Vermont population is upset and they will be go along with our agenda if we move there because they have nowhere else to go.
  • He said that there is not widespread discontent in Wyoming because the government is already so small in size and scope.
  • He said that the religious Republicans used to be discontent and that they tried to take Wyoming county by county.
  • He said they move from county x to county y – and are now in Platte County.
  • He said that they lost and the Republican Party has already moved away from them (but they have nowhere else to go).
  • He said some of them do not even vote any more.
  • The impression I got from everyone is that abortion is a losing issue in Wyoming, and so the Wyoming Republican Party is more inline with America on the issue than other state Republican Parties.
  • Bruce gave me ideas on where to hike in the Bighorn Mountains and asked me how my trip was doing.
  • It seems as though everyone is Wyoming unofficially works for the Department of Tourism as everyone asked me if I was having a good time.

  • I went on a free tour of the historic Sheridan Inn.
  • Apparently the Sheridan Inn was owned by Buffalo Bill Cody who also founded Cody, Wyoming.
  • According to the volunteer tour guide (who also happens to be a local school principal) Buffalo Bill used to be one of the most famous Americans in the world.
  • Sheridan is a town with lots of tourism and lots of retired people.
  • The area is very pretty and Sheridan looks like an authentic Western town.
  • There is a gentleman's club right across from the post office.
  • The town has four golf courses and looks absolutely beautiful.
  • I left Sheridan and entered Montana.
  • As soon as I got in Montana I noticed that I was on an Indian Reservation and that it was against the law to use the Interstate turnarounds.
  • In Wyoming it is legal to use the Interstate turnarounds – I even saw one sign that encouraged it.
  • I quickly left Montana and headed for the Bighorn Mountains.
  • There are two small towns between Sheridan and the Bighorn Mountains.
  • It was nice to see a drive-thru liquor store in a town with only 500 people.
  • Drive-thru liquor stores are all over Wyoming.
  • Sheridan's real estate is pretty steep.
  • Houses start around $70,000 and go up to around $800,000.
  • You can get a 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom house for around $125,000 if it is older and not near the mountains, and things go up from there.
  • The Bighorns were amazing and were much better than all of the other mountains I had ever been in (Smoky Mts, Green Mts, Adirondack, Casper Mt, Black Hills, Colorado Rockies)
  • There was a clear lake where less than a handful of people were fly fishing.
  • A long and clear stream fed the lake.
  • I played around in the stream and noticed a few leeches (or worms) but they wiped right off.
  • Now I feel that I have to go back to Wyoming just to spend more time hiking and climbing rocks in the Bighorn Mountains.
  • I talked to my Mom on the phone and she said the family is pushing for me to move to New Hampshire (almost 1/2 of my family live in Northern New England).
  • I noticed that there was a $30 hotel in Sheridan (a family business) but I stayed in a $40 hotel instead.
  • I felt sprinkles twice in Sheridan (this was the first time I had felt water since entering Wyoming).
July 26th
  • Gillette, Wyoming is the energy capital of the world (coal, oil, natural gas, etc.).
  • I noticed a restaurant called "Taco Time" in Moorcroft (near Gillette).
  • The lady at the counter said that it is a national chain from Oregon (I had never heard of it).
  • If that is true, Taco Time was the 4th national chain of taco restaurants that I saw in Wyoming.
  • I noticed that Wyoming has tons of miles of the Black Hills that are not government land.
  • I visited Devil's Tower National Monument.
  • People are not supposed to climb the tower without a permit, but I cannot imagine how they plan to enforce that rule.
  • The tower is spectacular and the views from about half way up are magnificent.
  • I was unable to climb any higher because after that point it became all crack climbing and I cannot climb cracks without the proper climbing gear.
  • The park ranger said the national monument gets around 5,000 visitors per day during the tourism season.
  • After Devil's Tower I visited Hulett, Sundance, and Aladdin, Wyoming.
  • Hulett, Wyoming has a small rally (that attracts 10,000 gearheads) and a topless rodeo during the Sturgis Rally.
  • Sundance, Wyoming has a topless drag race during the Sturgis Rally.
  • I found out that the Wyoming police are less strict than the South Dakota police during the Sturgis Rally.
  • ...in South Dakota until the evening of the 28th...
July 28th
  • Newcastle is a nice, inexpensive town.
  • It has a Pamida discount general/ drug store.
  • These stores are in small towns all over Wyoming and South Dakota.
  • The cashier said the store is a national chain and they even have stores in Tennessee.
  • My hotel room cost me $25 (it was a family business).
  • Newcastle is surrounded by the Black Hills of Wyoming on three sides and the prairie hills on the other side.
  • Newcastle would be a great town to retire in because it's in the Black Hills, is very inexpensive, and has everything most people need (local restaurants, chain restaurants, a pharmacy, a general store, a medical center, and all the other stuff).
  • Custer, SD is 45 minutes away and Rapid City is 80 minutes away.
  • The FSP could differently capitalize on the big Sturgis Motorcycle Rally by moving a lot of people (and changing the laws) into either Weston County (Newcastle) or the county above it (Crook County).
  • Both counties are in the Black Hills and very nice areas where property is inexpensive.
  • Jewel Cave National Monument is 25 minutes from Newcastle.
  • Jewel Cave is the 3rd largest cave in the world.
  • "Box work" cave formations are very neat and look like little (or big) boxes all over the walls.
  • A ranger at Jewel Cave said the park gets around 75,000 visitors per year.
  • Wind Cave National Park (which features a large prairie dog town and wild buffalo) is 45 minutes from Newcastle.
  • Wind Cave is the 6th largest cave in the world and contains about 95% of the world's cave "box work" formations.

Wrapping Up

Gambling
  • Wyoming has bingo centers (that you and I would call casinos) all over the state.
  • Wyoming has a horse track and Cheyenne, Casper, and Rock Springs have simulcast horse races from all over the country.
  • South Dakota has three different lotteries and casinos all over the Black Hills.
  • Almost every town in western South Dakota that I visited had a casino.
  • Deadwood, SD is a high casino and tourism town.
  • Most of these casinos are small and lots of them just have machines (like the casinos in MT and WY).
  • However, some of the SD casinos had a couple poker and black jack tables.
  • There was no ID check at the casino entrances.
  • I even saw a few kids walking around the casinos with their parents.

Hotels

  • Every town had a hotel for $40 per night (and more expensive ones also)
  • I did no research, but it was still easy to find a $30 hotel room in Sheridan and $25 hotel rooms in Newcastle and Torrington.
  • They were all family owned businesses (the hotels in the three towns above).
  • My hotel room in Casper cost $40, but the lowest-priced hotel I could find in Cheyenne was $80 (because of Cheyenne Frontier Days).
  • Normally there is a hotel that costs less than $40 in Cheyenne.
  • Two of the hotels that I stayed at in Wyoming did not even have bibles (a first for me).
  • All of the hotels had cable and HBO.

Housing Prices

  • Torrington, Guernsey, and Newcastle have very, very inexpensive housing – $35,000 to $50,000 and you can get a decent 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom house.
  • In Casper and Sheridan housing prices depend on how close to the mountains you live.
  • I did not checking housing prices anywhere else.
  • I heard someone say that in the towns near mountains, houses costs noticeably more than in the towns without mountains (and it makes sense).
  • However, Guernsey is surrounded by nice hills and Newcastle is surrounded by the Black Hills so I am not sure how true that is.

Comments about other candidate states

  • Mark (the president of the WSSA) said that Montana has a large environmentalist group and that they don't want to be free.
  • Beverly Spungin (the vice president of the WSSA) said that North Dakota is too flat for her (and she is from North Dakota)
  • Bruce Burns (R state Senator from Sheridan) said that Montana was too big and the people are too spread out for it to work.
  • Bruce Burns also said that we should pick Vermont because everyone would notice us if we kicked out the socialists and changed the makeup of Congress.
  • Of course, part of Bruce's argument would also work for South Dakota, because Tom Daschle is from SD.
  • John Schiffer (R state Senator from Kaycee) said that his daughter spent one winter in Portland, Maine and found it to be much worse than a Wyoming winter.
  • Michael (the executive director of the Wyoming Taxpayer Association) could not figure out why Idaho was on the list.
  • The general consensus was that Wyoming had harsh winters but the Northeast had even worse winters.

Mountains

  • Fort Collins has mountains but they are not covered in trees.
  • Casper Mountain and the other mountains near Casper, Wyoming are great.
  • Most of Casper Mountain is covered with trees but some parts are not and it even has ski and snowmobile trails.
  • The Bighorn Mountains stretch for seemingly miles and are magnificent.
  • The Bighorn Mountains have tons of skiing and snowmobiling and hiking and fishing.
  • These are mountains for the nature lover.
  • The Black Hills of Wyoming/South Dakota are very nice and cover a extremely large area.
  • There are highways that connect most of the Black Hills and the few places without highways have gravel roads.
  • The Black Hills attract millions of tourists every year.
  • Whether you want to fish, water ski, swim, hike, rock climb, sail, bike, gamble, or just sightsee, the Black Hills have something for you.
  • I did not see any of the other Wyoming mountain ranges.

Restaurants

  • I really do not know about restaurants.
  • I brought half my food.
  • For most of the rest I ate a combination of Chinese, Mexican, and fast food (like I normally do when I eat out).
  • Basically, I just ate like I normally do and that was very easy to do.
  • I also ate at a nice steak house and a couple of little diners (the food was good).
  • If you like Chinese, Mexican, fast food, Italian, diners, chain restaurants, and the other foods that Americans commonly eat you will hardly be inconvenienced by Wyoming.
  • I actually noticed types of restaurants in the Black Hills of South Dakota that are not even common to where I live (because the area is a tourist Mecca).

Radio

  • Rock (oldies, 70s, 80s, and modern), Country (60s to present), and Christian are the most popular types of music in Wyoming, if you judge by amount of radio stations.
  • National Public Radio is aired in almost every town.
  • Sheridan has two classical music stations (which also play operas).
  • Buffalo has one classical music station.
  • I enjoyed the country music stations more than the stations in the South because they played both old and modern country music.
  • Cheyenne has at least one Hits station that plays alternative rock, rap, R&B, and modern rock.
  • I could hear many of the Fort Collins stations in Cheyenne.
  • Casper has two stations that play alternative rock, rap, R&B, and modern rock.
  • Talk radio is found throughout Wyoming.

Cable and Internet

  • Every town that I stayed in had cable.
  • Every town had internet access.
  • My high-speed cell phone internet worked in every town I stayed in.

Alcohol and Drugs

  • It was nice to see drive-thru liquor stores even in towns with only 500 people.
  • People in Wyoming think Methamphetamine is a serious problem (if only they knew about Crack).
  • Wyoming is one of the places where politics can still take place at bars.
  • Some Wyoming towns already profit from the Sturgis Motorcycle Rally.
  • Hulett, WY has a small rally that attracts 10,000 gearheads.
  • Hulett also has a topless rodeo.
  • Sundance, WY has a topless drag race.
  • The police in Wyoming are known for being less strict during the rally than the police of South Dakota.
  • Because of the massive tourism that the Black Hills gets and this rally, there is a huge potential list of customers that we could draw into near-by Wyoming towns.
  • We just have to figure out what these potential customers want and how to make it happen (or legalize it)

Negatives

  • Bruce (state Senator from Sheridan) said there is not widespread discontent with state government.
  • The general consensus is that Wyoming is not overflowing with an unlimited supply of excessive jobs.
  • Parts of Wyoming get very hot in the summer (almost as hot as Boise, Idaho, but thankfully there is usually a nice breeze in these places).
  • I lost cell phone reception in areas near Gillette, Wyoming.
  • Hotel prices near Cheyenne go up during Cheyenne Frontier Days (by 100% to 200%).

Other things

  • Keith Goodenough (D) said that he wants us in Wyoming and could use us.
  • I asked Keith if he thought another state would be more receptive and he did not think so.
  • Keith told me that the Democrats in Wyoming have a higher NRA score than the Republicans.
  • I do not know about local politicians but the Wyoming Congressional Delegation (all Republican) has the best Gun Owners of American record in the nation so I am guessing that both political parties have great gun records.
  • John told me that they have preemption laws for guns in Wyoming. This means that Wyoming towns cannot pass gun laws that are more strict than the state laws.
  • Both Keith and John thought the majority of the voters in Wyoming support medical marijuana.
  • Mark Spungin homeschooled his kids and I asked him about the homeschooling laws in Wyoming. He said his family had no problems teaching his kids exactly what he wanted to teach them and that around 20 kids in his small town are homeschooled.
  • Mark told me about Boston T Party's book, Molon Labe. It's a fictional tale about a group like the FSP moving to Wyoming and slowing changing the minds of the people county by county.
  • Michael summed it up by saying that people in Wyoming have a "live and let live" attitude and don't care about your personal life.

Positives of not being in a large city

  • I'm from one of the largest cities in America, so being in Wyoming was dramatically different than what I am used to.
  • I've come to the conclusion that I liked living in Wyoming
  • The air was clear.
  • Never once did a smog or ozone warning come on the TV and tell me not to go outside!
  • Even though the speed limits were higher than I'm used to, people did not drive any faster than I'm used to.
  • It seems that people were more relaxed and calm and were not in a hurry to got everywhere.
  • Laid-back is a way of life.
  • I could see for miles and miles and miles.
  • I could actually see the stars at night!
  • Wyoming is the type of place that starts cooling off around 3 or 4 pm.
  • You can camp outside for most of the year.
  • If I sold the property I currently own and took my savings to Wyoming, I could buy a house and live the same quality of life I am currently living, for around $18,000 per year.
  • In other words, it costs very little to live in Wyoming.
  • Wyoming is SAFE!
  • There were not long lines at the stores.
  • Mom and Pop stores still exist.
  • People are friendly and helpful.
  • People are honest.
  • Mountains, mountains, and more mountains.
  • Deer are common, almost too common.
  • Hunting is big, I mean big.